Abortion ‘attack’ is democracy in action

Advances in fetal research since 1973 have established the unique, extrinsic, biological humanity of preborns.

Rich Elfers (“New Attacks on Roe v. Wade,” published May 22, 2019) seems to suspend critical thinking regarding the legal implications of the abortion debate.

While the plight of unwanted pregnancy may sometimes be pitiable, the end does not justify the means and this emotional argument has nothing to do with the constitutionality of abortion which is where the debate will inevitably lead.

Mr. Elfers is fond of lecturing his readers about government functions and U.S. history but in this case fails to recognize that the current debate is not an “attack” but rather a sublime example of our democracy in action.

Elfers suggests that moderates on both sides should compromise. However, if the Supreme Court considers a challenge to the current abortion law, that decision will be “winner take all” as was the case with Roe nearly 50 years ago. One need look no farther than the Dred Scott decision of 1857 and the subsequent 14th and 15th amendments to understand the legal considerations in play.

In the former, African Americans were considered less than full persons; in the latter, they were deemed to be full persons, not property (i.e., inalienable rights supersede property rights).

In a similar way, advances in fetal research (i.e., science) since 1973 have established the unique, extrinsic, biological humanity of preborns that the SCOTUS is unlikely to ignore.

I implore Mr. Elfers to use the space granted to him by this newspaper wisely.

Brian DiNielli


More in Letters to the Editor

Conspicuous Environmentalist, a poem

Refuse, Reuse, and Recycle please.

No more potholes at Community Center

Now our seniors and their walkers glide across the parking lot with ease.

Our national flag is being disrespected

Don’t misuse our flag to support other organizations or causes.

Protecting school choice is important

Without being able to choose his school, my son would not have been a successful student.

A son’s love on Mother’s Day

A White River School District student wrote this for his mother.

Bring in businesses, not housing, to downtown

There are enough developments happening around the rest of the city.

Sanger was a eugenicist, and that can’t be tolerated

She despised philanthropy and called for all “feeble-minded” men and women to not be able to reproduce.

Planned Parenthood is targeted by fake news

Its founder talked to anyone and everyone who was interested in abortion rights, even the KKK.

Abortion is murder. Period.

Even several prominent feminists agree.

We should be coming together

One of Mr. DuChateau’s column did the opposite.

Hitler, The Ku Klux Klan, and Margaret Sanger

Planned Parenthood clinics have followed along the same lines as its racist founder.

Kratom could help millions

So why is the FDA trying to schedule it?