Editor failed to be a fair moderator

Instead of framing the issues and allowing the readers to “form their own opinions on the matters at hand,” the editor chose to apply superfluous labels.

I appreciate that the Courier-Herald endeavored to spur thoughtful debate on the tension between the protections afforded Americans under the 1st and 14th Amendments to the Constitution. Thoughtful consideration of the balance between the two is vital to protect the liberties that we enjoy.

However, I was dismayed that Mr. Miller-Still promptly undermined his attempt to fairly moderate the debate. Instead of framing the issues and allowing the readers to “form their own opinions on the matters at hand,” the editor chose to apply superfluous labels to Ms. Stutzman’s legal counsel. He admonishes the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) as a “hate group”. This designation is applied by the Southern Poverty Law Center – an organization to which the reader is implicitly expected to abrogate their own critical faculties. Perhaps the ADF has a track record of blatant discrimination; however, Mr. Miller-Still never tells his readers what the firm has done to earn this moniker, yet they are expected to trust that it is warranted. Furthermore, the ADF is “right-wing” and “extreme”, two rather imprecise phrases that are subject to wide interpretation, but are used in this context to sow skepticism. Regardless, the labels present a smokescreen and are irrelevant to the issues. Alas, no broad characterizations are presented to describe the state’s assumedly measured intentions.

I agree with Mr. Miller-Still that “extreme bias should be met with extreme scrutiny”. I suppose we must look elsewhere for a moderator to lead a measured debate.

Chris Gruner

Enumclaw

More in Letters to the Editor

We should be coming together

One of Mr. DuChateau’s column did the opposite.

Kratom could help millions

So why is the FDA trying to schedule it?

Enumclaw really is a wonderful town

We just moved here, and love how friendly and accepting everyone is.

Thank you from WRRS

White River Senior Services thanks the community for supporting us.

Saying goodbye to a unique resident

I never talked to her, but I always appreciated her obvious determination.

Developers aren’t the problem — the Growth Management Act is

Growth is needed for Democrats to collect their taxes.

Have you looked at downtown Enumclaw lately?

We need to stop developers from turning our small town into a towering city.

Everyone can enjoy our senior center

It’s not just a place “where old people go.”

Be a decent hunter for the sake of others

Don’t leave your illegal kills out for my dog to eat.

Ferguson’s threats to conservative sheriffs are hypocritical

They’ve also sworn to uphold the Constitution.

Church and state are separated for our freedom

A response to a letter calling for the U.S. to return to God.