Writer’s criticism followed lead of Humpty Dumpty | Letter to the Editor

Upon reading the recent letter (Courier-Herald, Nov. 4) critiquing Rich Elfers’ column on freedom and chaos, I felt as if I had followed Alice down Lewis Carroll’s wondrous rabbit hole.

Upon reading the recent letter (Courier-Herald, Nov. 4) critiquing Rich Elfers’ column on freedom and chaos, I felt as if I had followed Alice down Lewis Carroll’s wondrous rabbit hole. Those familiar with Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland may remember her conversation with Humpty Dumpty during which he proceeded to instruct her in his version of semantics:

“When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it to mean neither more than less.”

“The question is,” said Alice, “whether you can make words mean so many different things.”

Fortunately, unlike Alice, we have handy access to dictionaries to serve as arbiters of meaning. After searching through, by actual count, 21 dictionaries, both physical and electronic, I discovered a general consensus on the meaning of the concept “freedom.” In varying forms, all of these sources generally agree that the contextually apropos definition of freedom as used by Mr Elfers is: the absence of coercion or constraint in choice or action; or, the power to act, speak or think as one wants without restraints. Based on his own words, it is obvious the letter writer does not approve of actions without constraint by laws or rules, which would certainly quality as chaos.

After a diligent search, I was able to run down the definition the letter writer referenced, only to find that it is not the definition of freedom, which he claimed; it is, in fact, the definition of virtue. I will readily agree that freedom is a virtue but the two words are entirely unrelated to each other in meaning except by, perhaps, Humpty Dumpty.

The letter, in truth, makes exactly the same point (“enforce the laws that protect citizens from aberrant behavior”) while attacking him for it. Chaos is exactly what occurs when there is no order. Chaos is another way of describing unconstrained “aberrant behavior,” which the writer obviously abhors.

It appears that the letter writer is “straining at a gnat” in his criticism of the column in order to denigrate what he considers a “liberal” and “arrogant” columnist. To criticize Elfers for attacking “virtue” while mis-defining it as “freedom” is, to coin a term, Humpty Dumptyish.

Robert DuChaine

Buckley

 

More in Letters to the Editor

What could go wrong with open borders?

Might as well open your home, too.

Ode to Donald

You’ve got spiders in your soul.

Elfers, don’t put words into my mouth

I may support our president, but that doesn’t mean you can assume my thoughts.

Optimism is the word for 2019

Sen. Phil Fortunato writes about revenue flowing into state coffers, and how its time to give taxpayers a break.

Kim Schrier, fight for Alzeimer’s research and care

There are more than 110,000 people living with Alzheimer’s or other dementias in our state alone.

They’re laughing their way to the bank

This year I will pay forced tribute of over a $1,000 to the Regional Transit Authority for the “privilege” of driving in Washington.

I’ll never think about trains the same way again

“At birth, we boarded the train and met our parents, and we believe they will always travel on our side.”

Time running out for Bonney Lake history?

As a volunteer non-profit, it’s hard to keep the ball rolling.

Congrats, Superintendent Nelson

You and the Enumclaw School District Board of Directors deserve the honors you received.

Arts Alive! not affected by City Council budget

People have confused the non-profit with the city art department.

Thank you for all the support

We are thankful to live in such a loving community.

Thank you for returning the memories

We built this car in the ’90s, and we’re so glad to have it back.