Enumclaw and Buckley settle dispute with offer of $100,000

The continuing cash clash between Enumclaw city officials and their Buckley counterparts eventually came to include complex engineering data, municipal mathematical methodologies and legal legwork.

The continuing cash clash between Enumclaw city officials and their Buckley counterparts eventually came to include complex engineering data, municipal mathematical methodologies and legal legwork.

But that didn’t force the two sides any closer to settling a dispute over past payments related to the natural gas system that serves residents of both Plateau communities.

But, eventually, money talks. And $100,000 made the ongoing troubles disappear.

The history between the two towns that straddle the White River might be one of mutual agreement, but it seemed there was no middle ground when it came to the recent fracas. Enumclaw claimed it was owed nearly a half-million dollars by its neighbor in Pierce County and equally adamant were those at Buckley City Hall, who asserted they owed nothing.

The fiscal flap came to a skidding stop when Buckley offered $100,000 to make the lingering problem go away.

A brief – and simplified – bit of history

Natural gas service to both Enumclaw and Buckley dates back to 1957. Gas transmission lines run from Auburn, through Enumclaw on to Buckley. Buckley has always paid Enumclaw a fee. The current contract was executed in 1972 and amended twice, in 1983 and 1995.

In recent years, Buckley determined it could not effectively operate its own natural gas  system. Citizens voted to dispose of the utility and a sale to Puget Sound Energy for $5.4 million is scheduled to close on June 30.

That’s where Enumclaw enters the picture. PSE and Enumclaw need to negotiate a new “transportation agreement” so the flow of natural continues unimpeded to Buckley.

As an offshoot of that process, Enumclaw officials determined that Buckley had historically paid too little for what it received. Buckley maintains it paid exactly what the contract called for.

Two letters were delivered from Enumclaw City Hall to Buckley City Hall during the last half of April. The first stated that Buckley owed Enumclaw $388,654; the second letter upped the figure to nearly $475,000.

 

Buckley gets legal advice

Buckley has employed the Seattle law firm of Ogden Murphy Wallace, which reviewed Enumclaw’s claims for retroactive payments. Finding were presented in a May 2 letter to Buckley Mayor Pat Johnson.

In her subsequent letter to Enumclaw, Johnson wrote, “Buckley vigorously disputes that it owes any money” due to capital improvements to the gas system and, further, the city refuted the methodology used to establish Enumclaw’s claim.

Citing a statute of limitation on contractual items, Buckley was advised by its attorneys that, at most, it could be liable only for expenses since April 2008.

“We believe Enumclaw has slept on its right for too long to recover anything,” with a small, possible exception, the attorney’s letter states. The most Buckley would owe, the attorney stated, was $9,566.

 

Offer of compromise

Buckley’s most recent letter said it “wants to be a good neighbor, it wishes to put this entire matter behind it and it does not want this issue to interfere with the closing of the sale to PSE.”

With that, Buckley offered $100,000 to settle the issue.

The letter gave Enumclaw until May 14 to accept the cash settlement. Enumclaw took action May 12.

More in News

Black Diamond hits the reset button

The new Black Diamond City Council wasted no time on settling in and testing the political waters. On their first meeting of the year, new Councilwomen Melissa Oglesbee and Erin Stout and returning Councilwomen Tamie Deady and Janie Edelman marched through a long list of agenda items, many of which reversed council policies and goals set over the last two years.

Citizen group urges council to start pool planning

With the Sumner High School pool closing at the end of the 2018-2019 swim season, residents are asking the City of Bonney Lake to build a city pool to house the Panther and Spartan swim teams. A presentation on why the council should start planning a pool as quickly as possible is being held Tuesday, Jan. 23.

Teacher, student reconnect at living center after 66 years

A person can change in 66 years. At the very least, they’re going to look pretty different. So when Robert Terrell, 96, and Margaret (Peggy) Burley, 75, ran into each other at Bonney Lake’s Cedar Ridge assisted living facility last August, neither of them realized they had met before — at an elementary school, where he was a fourth-grade teacher, and she was a part of his first ever class.

Former Plateau resident lands role with Marvel T.V. series

McKay Stewart, who spent much of his childhood in Enumclaw and Bonney Lake, will be joining the Marvel universe in a new episode of “Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.” airing Friday, Jan. 19.

Library’s art and writing contest returns to Pierce County | Pierce County Library System

Pierce County teens are encouraged to express themselves through writing, painting, drawing and more for the annual Our Own Expressions competition, hosted by the Pierce County Library System.

Sumner School District seeks name ideas for new elementary school

Want to name your new local school? Just fill out a short form by Jan. 26

Judge reproaches Black Diamond mayor, former city council majority

In a summary judgement hearing, King County Superior Court Judge Janet Helson said she was troubled by both the actions of Black Diamond Mayor Carol Benson and former City Council majority Pat Pepper, Brian Weber, and Erika Morgan over the last two years concerning potential Open Public Meetings Act violations.

Man shot in Burnett; suspect turns himself in

According to the Pierce County Sheriff’s Department, the victim was driven to the Burnett Store in order to report he was shot by his brother. The suspect turned himself in approximately three hours later.

Garbage, water, sewer rates increase in Enumclaw

Having made the leap into a new year, Enumclaw property owners are now seeing increases to nearly all their utility rates. Here’s a look at the 2018 increases for city services, along with the financial impact on customers.

Most Read