Enumclaw pastor Malcolm Fraser guilty verdict | Inside the Courtroom

It took two hours, 20 minutes for a jury of 12 to find Enumclaw Sound Doctrine pastor Malcolm Fraser guilty of two counts of first-degree child rape and two counts of first-degree molestation of a child.

It took two hours, 20 minutes for a jury of 12 to find Enumclaw Sound Doctrine pastor Malcolm Fraser guilty of two counts of first-degree child rape and two counts of first-degree molestation of a child.

A sentencing date was not announced May 29 when the jury returned its verdict. Superior Court Judge Lori K. Smith stated the date will be set later.

The initial sentencing range information is Fraser is facing 20 to 25 years and a possible fine of $50,000.

The verdict

The jury began deliberations at 2 p.m. May 28, following closing arguments and instructions from the judge. The jury ended deliberations at 4 p.m. and returned at 9 a.m. May 29. At 9:20 the court bailiff was notified the jury had reached a verdict.

Defense Attorney Ann Carey had to come from her office in Seattle while Malcolm Fraser and his wife Julie came from Enumclaw.

Both were delayed by serious traffic accidents in separate parts of the South Sound.

Members of Sound Doctrine Church began filtering into the courtroom about 9:30 a.m., including those who maintain the church website, Enumclaw.com.

The outward sense in the courtroom from church members prior to the Fraser and Carey’s arrival was relaxed, almost jovial.

Carey reached the court at 10:30 a.m. Shortly after, word went through the room Fraser was parking.

By the time Fraser arrived at 10:45, about 20 people, some members of the church, filled the seats behind the defense table. He was dressed in a dark suit with white shirt and tie.

His wife, Julie Fraser, sat in the front behind and to the right of Fraser. Abigail Davidson sat next to Julie Fraser to provide sign language for her during the reading of the verdict. Julie Fraser is deaf.

When Fraser entered the courtroom and took his seat he turned to the group, smiled and waved. Josiah Williams, the senior pastor of Sound Doctrine, who testified during the trial, was present. Tim Williams, the Sound Doctrine founder, was not.

The room became quiet and the tension rose as the Deputy Prosecutor Jason Simmons arrived at 10:47 a.m. and took his seat.

Two King County Sheriff’s deputies stood at the door.

The bailiff asked the attorneys if they were ready for the judge.

All Rise

The judge entered King County Superior Courtroom 4C at 10:59 a.m. to the bailiff’s call of, “All rise.”

The judge took her seat and said the “word from the jury is they have a verdict.”

The judge looked to the spectators and said in a calm but firm tone that she realized this had been an emotional case, but, “You will keep your decorum or you will be forced to leave.”

With that statement she directed the bailiff to bring the jury into the courtroom.

As the members filed in they looked serious and somber. The judge asked the presiding juror if they had reached a verdict.

“We have,” he said.

The judge then asked if the verdict had been signed.

“We have,” he said.

The bailiff then gave the verdict to the judge and she asked the court clerk to read the verdict.

The clerk read the charge of first-degree rape of a child and said, “Guilty.”

Sobs broke out from members of the church. Fraser stood still and did not react.

Three more times the clerk said, “Guilty.”

Following the reading of the verdict the judge polled the jury and each said clearly they found Fraser guilty as charged.

Fraser turned to his wife and spoke to her with sign language. Julie Fraser was crying and the other members of the church were sobbing.

At that point the prosecutor said the state was requesting Fraser be taken into custody and the judge concurred. Smith asked the spectators to leave the courtroom as the deputies took Fraser into custody. He would be escorted through a door he had sat 10 feet away from since April 3 when the trial began. The double-locked door leads into the jail.


The State vs. Malcolm John Fraser criminal trial spanned two months. The jury was comprised of four women and eight men.

Fraser did not take the stand to testify.

He was arrested in March 2012 and entered a plea of not guilty in April 2012. He had been free on bail while awaiting the trial.

Fraser was convicted of raping and molesting a girl while he lived with her family in Enumclaw.  Fraser was living in the house as an assistant pastor for the church with his wife, Julie Fraser. He also worked at WinePress Publishing, a Christian self-publishing business located in Enumclaw. WinePress is owned by Sound Doctrine.

The rape and molestation of the girl began when she was 10 and continued when she as 11. She is now 18 years old.

The young woman who brought the charges forward was on the stand for three days.


A juror was willing to give an interview to this publication. The juror’s interview and impressions of the trial from inside the jury room will be next.


More in News

Former Plateau resident lands role with Marvel T.V. series

McKay Stewart, who spent much of his childhood in Enumclaw and Bonney Lake, will be joining the Marvel universe in a new episode of “Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.” airing Friday, Jan. 19.

Black Diamond hits the reset button

The new Black Diamond City Council wasted no time on settling in and testing the political waters. On their first meeting of the year, new Councilwomen Melissa Oglesbee and Erin Stout and returning Councilwomen Tamie Deady and Janie Edelman marched through a long list of agenda items, many of which reversed council policies and goals set over the last two years.

Citizen group urges council to start pool planning

With the Sumner High School pool closing at the end of the 2018-2019 swim season, residents are asking the City of Bonney Lake to build a city pool to house the Panther and Spartan swim teams. A presentation on why the council should start planning a pool as quickly as possible is being held Tuesday, Jan. 23.

Bonney Lake releases findings on water meter tests, ends internal audit

Dozens of residents complained to the council last October about what they called impossibly high water bills. After several months performing an internal audit of the water utility system, including testing 43 water meters from homes that received a high water bills, the city holds there is no bug in the system, and residents used the amount of water recorded on their bills. But some residents, and even councilmembers, remain unconvinced.

White River Valley Museum opens “Suffer for Beauty” exhibit

Corsets, bras, and bustles, oh my! The White River Valley Museum is hosting its new event, “Suffer for Beauty,” which is all about the changing ideals of female beauty through the ages. The exhibit runs through June 17.

Teacher, student reconnect at living center after 66 years

A person can change in 66 years. At the very least, they’re going to look pretty different. So when Robert Terrell, 96, and Margaret (Peggy) Burley, 75, ran into each other at Bonney Lake’s Cedar Ridge assisted living facility last August, neither of them realized they had met before — at an elementary school, where he was a fourth-grade teacher, and she was a part of his first ever class.

Library’s art and writing contest returns to Pierce County | Pierce County Library System

Pierce County teens are encouraged to express themselves through writing, painting, drawing and more for the annual Our Own Expressions competition, hosted by the Pierce County Library System.

Sumner School District seeks name ideas for new elementary school

Want to name your new local school? Just fill out a short form by Jan. 26

Judge reproaches Black Diamond mayor, former city council majority

In a summary judgement hearing, King County Superior Court Judge Janet Helson said she was troubled by both the actions of Black Diamond Mayor Carol Benson and former City Council majority Pat Pepper, Brian Weber, and Erika Morgan over the last two years concerning potential Open Public Meetings Act violations.

Most Read