Big Brother headed to Washington?

  • Monday, March 30, 2009 8:54pm
  • Opinion

Imagine you and your family sitting down to dinner when there’s a thunderous knock at the door. You open the door to find two uniformed men standing on your porch.

“Good evening,” they say. “We’re with the State Mileage Militia and we need to see your car. Please get your keys and take us to your garage.”

Far-fetched? Hopefully.

With no fanfare and very little public discussion, state lawmakers in 2008 established targets for how many miles you and I can drive each year. It’s called VMT – Vehicle Miles Traveled. Aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions, the legislation calls for cutting the number of miles we drive by 18 percent by 2020, 30 percent by 2035 and 50 percent by 2050.

This session, lawmakers are proposing to have regional transportation planning organizations figure out how to reach the VMT targets. The options include restricting suburban development, increasing population density in urban growth areas, toll roads, congestion pricing, raising parking prices or banning parking altogether.

Many think we will eventually have a VMT tax – a tax on each mile we drive. In Europe, the Netherlands will transition to a VMT by 2014 and Denmark is set to implement theirs in 2016.

By that time, we won’t need the Mileage Militia to track our mileage. It will be done remotely by sensors in our cars. Science fiction? Not at all.

Currently, many new cars are equipped with on-board GPS mapping systems. These computers do more than provide directions. They store information on how far you drive, where you go, how fast you drive and if you slam on the brakes too often. When the technology becomes standard within the next several years, the government need only use remote sensors to record the information from your passing car.

Does it feel a little like Big Brother is watching?

There are so many things wrong with this VMT approach I don’t know where to begin.

First of all, the original 2008 legislation was pushed through below the radar screen. Janet Ray of AAA Washington says, “We don’t think there has been enough analysis of impacts on the economy and people’s mobility. The benchmarks for reducing an individual’s VMT were inserted at the last minute last year – there was no time to vet the numbers or have the public take a look at it.”

Even as VMT moves forward, a lot of unanswered questions remain. How will the VMT impact global warming? (No one knows.) How will this affect our economy? (No answer.)

While the limits may make sense in urban areas with mass transit, what about people who live in rural communities? Imposing a one-size-fits-all target is unfair.

If mileage limits are ultimately assessed on individual drivers, what happens to people whose jobs require them to drive a hundred miles a day? What will sales reps and plumbers and electricians do when they hit their mileage limits – refuse to serve customers? Lawmakers don’t have an answer.

Forcing people to live in cities with limited housing stock will drive up prices. Where will middle class and low-income people find affordable housing? What about the people who want to raise their kids in a house with a yard?

If we succeed in cutting our miles driven by 50 percent, where will the state get the gas tax revenue for highway and bridge maintenance? Activists are adamant that VMT fees, fines and taxes will not be used for highways.

The bottom line is VMT is the wrong approach. We don’t need to be punished or coerced. When people are educated and encouraged to do the right thing, they come through every time.

Washington has some great incentive programs and lawmakers should expand those, rather than focusing on reducing choices and limiting our mobility.

Currently, some 250,000 drivers at 800 companies and 1,100 worksites across the state take part in the Commute Trip Reduction Program of subsidized bus passes, van pools and carpools. In fact, Washington has one of the top programs in the nation.

As of this January, purchases of new hybrid or flex-fuel cars are exempt from the sales tax. Ironically, by focusing on miles driven rather than fuel used, the VMT treats gas guzzlers and hybrids alike.

The people of Washington don’t need legislators and regional planners figuring out ways to control our behavior. And we don’t need Big Brother watching our every move.

Don Brunell is president of the Association of Washington Business.

More in Opinion

U.S., Russia agree on Middle East situation

Since Russia helped Syria’s Bashar al-Assad stay in power and helped to defeat ISIS, are Russia and the U.S. at odds in the Middle East? Is Russia threatening American dominance in the region? The answer to both is no.

Page-turners: Best books of 2017

Continuing an end-of-year tradition that dates back more than 15 years, the King County Library System has chosen its Best Books of 2017.

Anthem protests about equality, not disrespect

For all who write negative comments about the football players who took a knee and posted that “this is not the America we grew up in,” let me share a few of the personal events from my life growing up in Tacoma Washington as a white woman.

Trump supporters’ attitude still the same

“Support Trump? Sure,” she said. “I like him.” These words by Pam Shilling from Trump Country western Pennsylvania reflect what many Trump supporters are thinking a year after the 2016 election victory, according to an article excerpted from “” by “The Week” (Dec. 1, 2017).

Readers note: Change in comments section

The Courier-Herald has switched to a different online reader-comments platform.

Former fan finished with disrespectful NFL players

I lived off the grid for 15 years and the one thing I missed the most was watching pro football.

Carrying firearms about to change at the state Capitol

If you come to the state Capitol and want to see lawmakers in action, there are a few rules to follow while sitting in the galleries overlooking the Senate and the House floors.

America’s monster

I’m not sure when it happened, but I recently realized I’ve stopped asking myself, “What are we going to do about mass shootings and gun violence in this country?” Instead, I now ask, “When is the carnage going to come to Enumclaw?”

Avoiding loss means more than gaining something else

Some studies have shown that losses are twice as psychologically powerful as gains. American history and our current political situation help reveal a great deal about the American/human psyche.

Congratulations, Jan Molinaro

In every election, one person must win and the other will lose. Now more than ever, it is important to show our children how to be gracious in victory and humble in defeat.

Don’t give into the pressure of driving drowsy

Eleven years ago, a drowsy-driving car wreck left me with injuries that still challenge me today.

Opening our minds can be a beautiful thing

As a leader of my church’s Sunday Adult Forum, I had a goal: to put a human face on Islam for the members of the congregation and community.