Considering school class sizes | Rich Elfers

How big should your child’s class size be? According to State Initiative 1351, which barely passed recently, smaller is better.

  • by
  • Thursday, February 5, 2015 8:40pm
  • Opinion

How big should your child’s class size be? According to state Initiative 1351, which barely passed recently, smaller is better. It seems to be common sense: the fewer the children, the easier it is for teachers to do their jobs. Fewer students mean fewer disruptions and more teacher contact time.

But is this assumption really backed by facts? Not according to Malcolm Gladwell in his recent book, “David and Goliath.” His assertions have created a controversy in academia.

Gladwell, also author of popular books such as “The Tipping Point,” “Blink” and “Outlier,” states: “A smaller classroom only translates to a better outcome if teachers change their teaching style when given a lower workload. Evidence suggests that teachers don’t necessarily do that.”

Having taught high school level social studies now for nearly 40 years, I find his argument provocative. I taught classes with numbers as high as 32 and as low as seven. I believe there is truth to his assertions.

Gladwell argues having many students makes the job of teaching more difficult in terms of discipline and papers to correct. That is true. Having few students means fewer discipline issues and less work outside the classroom. That’s also true. Gladwell asserts there is a sweet spot between too many and too few students.

My experience in teaching high school students found the ideal size to be between 24 and 26 students per class. There is certainly a tipping point in terms of class dynamics when that magic number is passed in American schools. Maintaining order and focus is more difficult with an extra two or three more.

I have found that smaller class sizes lose a certain dynamic in discussions. There are not as many differences in opinion and since fewer students are there to support a quieter student’s views, there is less chance that student will speak up. A quiet student needs greater numbers to give them confidence to know that their views have validity.

Larger class sizes have a different dynamic during discussions. The more students in class, the more opinions and attitudes are likely to vary. There is more likelihood that student comments and perceptions will create sparks.

Those who favor smaller class sizes point to elite schools where numbers range between 10 and 12. Gladwell counters this argument by stating: “Wealthy people, and wealthy institutions, and wealthy nations – all Goliaths – too often fall into (error): the school assumes that the kind of things that wealth can buy all translate into real world advantages.”

Just because the rich can afford to send their children to private schools does not automatically mean students will be getting a better education. These are assumptions that may not bear the light of critical analysis.

There are other factors that we in America often are not aware of. I’ve visited high schools in Japan where the average class size is closer to 40. Teachers seem to be able to maintain order because the culture is different. There is respect for teachers in the culture because of the influence of Confucianism.

I currently teach classes in high school completion at a nearby college with mainly international (Asian) students. Maintaining order is not even much of an issue there. Of course, correcting papers with larger class sizes remains the same, with the additional burden that English is their second language.

Whatever the answer to the right class size, Gladwell stirred up a lot of controversy. The passing of Initiative 1351 in this state needs to have its assumptions carefully researched. Smaller class sizes mean greater cost to the taxpayers of the state. The question that has not been answered is whether that unfunded mandate will give us the bang for the buck the majority hoped for.

More in Opinion

The times, they are a-changin’

My friends, Artificial Intelligence (AI) is advancing in such leaps and bounds it boggles my imagination.

Thank you Murray for increasing Alzheimer’s research funding

As someone who helped care for a mother with Alzheimer’s and who now misses her every day, I understand firsthand the impact this disease has on families across America.

Tribalism led to the loss of Vietnam, Iraq wars

Knowing and understanding tribalism can offer a solution to the divisions at home and abroad.

The Fennel Creek Trail will benefit nearby communities

Contrary to the beliefs of some, the increased number of people using trails discourages criminal activities by increasing the number of eyes watching what is going on.

The sweetest revenge? Sometimes it’s just being nice

Being kind to others, especially those who have harmed or hurt us, comes as a result of seeing others as our equals.

Mental health competency delays cost state millions

Soon, some of those languishing lengthy periods behind bars might need to be released and charges against them dismissed.

State Dems may abandon caucus chaos in 2020

Last week the state Democratic Party signaled a greater ope nness to allocate delegates ba sed on the results of the prim ary rather than caucuses, whic h it’s never done before.

The four cornerstones of arguing irrationally

Don’t get caught up in the techniques people use to ignore rational arguments.

State Dems may abandon caucus chaos in time for 2020

Washington also is considering becoming more significant by moving its primary to early March.

A taste of Krain history, from its dive-bar days

I first went in the place one winter’s evening when I was 8 or 9 years old.

Supreme Court resets the playing field

The ruling on the Masterpiece Bakery v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission case wasn’t a win for the right or a loss for the left; it’s a chance to do things right the second time around.

Supreme Court ruling shows sanity, moderation

The 14th Amendment equal protection clause does not negate the First Amendment religious freedom clause.