More on why Enumclaw shouldn’t allow gated communities | Letter to the Editor

Previously, I expressed reservations about the Planning Commission's proposed gated development section of Enumclaw's Comprehensive Plan (Courier-Herald, May 8). Essentially, my objections were that the enclosed housing tracts would thwart the stated goal of the Comprehensive Plan to enhance connections across the town and that a market-driven approach is not a plan, but the absence of one.

Previously, I expressed reservations about the Planning Commission’s proposed gated development section of Enumclaw’s Comprehensive Plan (Courier-Herald, May 8). Essentially, my objections were that the enclosed housing tracts would thwart the stated goal of the Comprehensive Plan to enhance connections across the town and that a market-driven approach is not a plan, but the absence of one.

After reading the other comments on file with the city, I would like to make a further point. A letter supporting the gated developments argued that our neighbors are doing it and we shouldn’t be left behind. I would counter that we are a unique community. We should capitalize on our assets and not try to imitate neighbors whose circumstances are very different from ours. What we have is a distinct downtown surrounded by nearby neighborhoods. What we don’t have are proximity to major employment clusters and vast tracts of land within the city limits.

Compare our situation to two of our neighbors, Bonney Lake and Black Diamond. Bonney Lake is a large housing region with a highway through the center, but without a downtown. What they do have is ample acreage for mega-development. And commute times there are considerably shorter than from Enumclaw.

Black Diamond also has a shorter commute and land for mega-development. Like Enumclaw, Black Diamond had a central core and a sense of community. But as you have read here in the Courier-Herald, that community has been divided by the prospect of market-driven development.

Enumclaw should not try to replicate our neighbors. We cannot shorten the commute from here and the scale of our developments will certainly be dwarfed by what we will see in these other places. What we can do is take advantage of a unique asset – a downtown core connected to adjacent neighborhoods.

Why would people want to drive the extra distance and move to Enumclaw to live behind a gate when they could find the same thing much closer to work? But many would accept the longer commute and choose Enumclaw because it offered something very different, something they couldn’t find elsewhere.

A goal of the Comprehensive Plan is to build connections across Enumclaw neighborhoods and with the city center. Targeting high-end homebuyers and enclosing them in exclusive locations would run counter to the goal of connecting the community. Such a strategy would divide our unique town instead.

At a recent Planning Commission meeting, members discussed dropping the requirement for three-car garages. It is one thing for a home buyer to choose a three-car garage, but quite another for the city to mandate it. This language in the plan is, in fact, what caught my eye about the whole issue. However, removing that specific requirement does not solve the problem. It is gated developments themselves, not the restrictions within them, that would isolate segments of our town.

The Planning Commission has worked hard to create a forward-looking plan. Except for one paragraph, the 162-page document offers a coherent vision for the future of a special town. If you agree, please urge them to drop the gated development section the Comprehensive Plan. You can reach the Planning Commission members through They will present their recommendations to the City Council members, who make the final decision, at

John Anderson


More in Opinion

Maybe it’s time Congress takes back its power

The Constitution gives Congress the most power of the three branches of government.

Poking dead things with sticks

They don’t mince words when they call it a “crawl space,” do they?

America is denying three hard truths

There are three major hard truths that our current government has been denying with great vigor: The Mueller Russia-U.S. Presidential election connection investigation, the war in Afghanistan, and the growing national deficit.

Promote the common good by ensuring individual liberty

Citizens following their passions and dreams improve the lot for all.

The three personas of President Trump

There’s Teleprompter Trump, Raw Meat Trump and Twitter Trump.

Attitudes change on farming non-native salmon

Their warnings fell on deaf ears, but the tables have turned on the fish farming industry in Washington.

Voting yes on levies means investing in our kids’ future

We are White River graduates. Our parents are White River graduates. Our siblings are White River graduates, and our kids will one day be White River graduates.

Voting for the levy with make a major #impact for our schools

I have four children in Enumclaw public schools and they all benefit from programs that are supported by the renewal of the operational levy.

Great schools mean great communities

As former elected School Board Member, State Legislator and King County Judge, we understand the importance of educating all children.

Political soap opera won’t end until midterm elections

Democrats and Republicans in Congress, as well as President Trump, have all taken gambles that will shape the November midterms.

A small act of kindness can make a big impact | SoHaPP

Join SoHaPP’s book group this February to discuss “Wonder” by R.J. Palacio. Don’t have the book? Check it out at the Enumclaw Library or visit The Sequel.

Vote ‘yes’ on replacement Education Programs levy

As a high school senior that has spent the entirety of my school life in Enumclaw, I know we have to take it upon ourselves to ensure the efficiency and inclusiveness of our school system.