Understanding geography of red, blue | Rich Elfers

Do you know why blue (Democratic) states are clustered in the Northeast and along the West Coast on national election maps? Or why red (Republican) states are concentrated in the Great Plains and the South? Why do Pierce, King, Snohomish, and Spokane counties in Washington state almost always vote Democratic while the rest of the state votes Republican?

  • by
  • Monday, March 9, 2015 5:38pm
  • Opinion

Do you know why blue (Democratic) states are clustered in the Northeast and along the West Coast on national election maps? Or why red (Republican) states are concentrated in the Great Plains and the South? Why do Pierce, King, Snohomish, and Spokane counties in Washington state almost always vote Democratic while the rest of the state votes Republican?

There’s a reason for this based upon geography.

Geography affects the way we think more than we realize. Why are rural areas most often conservative and Republican, while big cities with a population of more than 500,000 are predominantly Democratic? The answers to some of these questions come from my own life experiences.

In the late 1970s my wife, kids and I moved to the rural part of my county and bought 10 acres.  Why did we want so much property? We wanted to raise our children in nature with animals. We also wanted to be self-sufficient. Owning land meant we could grow our own food. It meant a higher sense of security. Only later did I come to realize that owning land also meant that if the government collapsed, someone would take the land from me by force. It was false security.

I think this illusion of self-sufficiency and security is why few conservatives live in big cities. There are also few minorities who are citizens who live in more rural areas. These areas are mostly white. Older whites, especially males, tend to vote predominantly Republican.

When one lives closer to nature, there are fewer changes except the ongoing changes in the seasons. Conservatives favor keeping conditions as they are. Any major changes can mean loss of status and wealth. Conservatives are often business owners and there are more taxes and government regulation in the urban areas as opposed to living in less populated areas.

Democrats often live in big cities for several reasons: minorities like to live among their own, just like whites who favor the suburbs and more rural areas. Cities constantly are changing.  Change is valued more highly by progressives, because it means that improvement of opportunities is more likely.

Since most of the big U.S. population centers along the coast vote predominantly Democratic, people who live in those areas more frequently tend to come in contact with those from other countries and cultures and colors. This greater diversity tends to force people to be more open to allowing for differences in values and attitudes, making them more Democratic when voting.

Being in and around nature is more difficult to see in cities. Buildings go down and are replaced by new structures. The skylines are not mountains, but man-made constructions: buildings and bridges. People come to the cities to find work in the factories and businesses that locate there. Working for someone else encourages the rise of unions.

Because Republican President Abraham Lincoln was credited with freeing the slaves, blacks voted solidly Republican as a block until the Great Depression when Franklin Roosevelt’s administration pushed for laws to help minorities and the poor. Then they switched to voting Democratic.

After the Civil War ended in 1865, whites in southern states voted solidly Democratic until the mid-1960s. Then the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act were passed. After that, southern whites have voted consistently Republican.

The poor in Red States vote conservative because of the issues of abortion and gay rights. These issues go against their more conservative religious views. This group also tends to live where there is less diversity in rural areas. Those who are pro-choice and for gay marriage tend to live in more urbanized areas.

Most of western Washington votes Democratic because most of the counties mentioned above are the most urbanized. Educated professionals also tend to live in and around cities and they now vote predominantly Democratic.

Geography affects one’s political and religious outlook. Geography determines how much or how little change will occur. These differences affect how and why people vote the way they do. It makes the three west coast states vote predominantly Democratic and the Midwest and South vote consistently Republican. Awareness of these tendencies helps explain the differences between western and eastern Washington. We seem to be much more affected by our geography than we are probably aware.


More in Opinion

A taste of Krain history, from its dive-bar days

I first went in the place one winter’s evening when I was 8 or 9 years old.

Supreme Court resets the playing field

The ruling on the Masterpiece Bakery v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission case wasn’t a win for the right or a loss for the left; it’s a chance to do things right the second time around.

Supreme Court ruling shows sanity, moderation

The 14th Amendment equal protection clause does not negate the First Amendment religious freedom clause.

Initiative signatures are the new greenbacks

As of Wednesday, June 6, petitions for four statewide initiatives were getting circulated.

Public record battle brings in a mediator

A taskforce is also being put together, but it’s not clear who will be on it.

Trump supporters see the president doing ‘God’s will on Earth’

Why did Truman recognize Israel so quickly and why do we care about modern Israel, enough to bring the ire of the Muslim world down upon us?

Eyman risking retirement funds on car tab initiative

Will the $500,000 investment be enough to get the initiative on a ballot?

U.S. isn’t the only nation flirting with trade wars

There’s another brewing between Alberta and British Columbia.

I wish I could stay in Enumclaw | Guest Columnist

There is a kindness and decency and desire to be a community in Enumclaw.

We live in frightening times

Our country is being torn apart from limb to limb, coast to coast.

Voting habits tied to feelings of security

The dangers of authoritarianism are a far greater threat to the nation than seeing rising racial equality and religious diversity brought about by immigration.

Gun rights advocates won the battle, but may lose the war

NRA leaders will need to decide if it’s worth putting resources into a fight in a Left Coast state versus investing in efforts to keep Republicans in control of Congress to prevent ideas like this initiative from becoming federal law.