Abortion ‘attack’ is democracy in action

Advances in fetal research since 1973 have established the unique, extrinsic, biological humanity of preborns.

Rich Elfers (“New Attacks on Roe v. Wade,” published May 22, 2019) seems to suspend critical thinking regarding the legal implications of the abortion debate.

While the plight of unwanted pregnancy may sometimes be pitiable, the end does not justify the means and this emotional argument has nothing to do with the constitutionality of abortion which is where the debate will inevitably lead.

Mr. Elfers is fond of lecturing his readers about government functions and U.S. history but in this case fails to recognize that the current debate is not an “attack” but rather a sublime example of our democracy in action.

Elfers suggests that moderates on both sides should compromise. However, if the Supreme Court considers a challenge to the current abortion law, that decision will be “winner take all” as was the case with Roe nearly 50 years ago. One need look no farther than the Dred Scott decision of 1857 and the subsequent 14th and 15th amendments to understand the legal considerations in play.

In the former, African Americans were considered less than full persons; in the latter, they were deemed to be full persons, not property (i.e., inalienable rights supersede property rights).

In a similar way, advances in fetal research (i.e., science) since 1973 have established the unique, extrinsic, biological humanity of preborns that the SCOTUS is unlikely to ignore.

I implore Mr. Elfers to use the space granted to him by this newspaper wisely.

Brian DiNielli

Enumclaw




Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@courierherald.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.courierherald.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 500 words or less.

More in Letters to the Editor

Trump does the work, while politicians do nothing

He’s not perfect, but he’s the best we’ve got.

Elfers fails to read past the Consitution’s preamble

“Promoting the general welfare” is not a basis for overreaching government powers.

Courier-Herald missed the mark on “downtown cruise” article

It was important to mention the safety hazards of the event, but the focus was too skewed.

COVID and cousins

A poem about the virus.

Trump is a sickness worse than COVID

Being a leader means taking responsibility.

Thank you for continuing to print

I know how difficult it can be to put out a paper even during the best of times.

Don’t politicize a positive community event

The article about the downtown cruise was nothing but negative.

Please keep up the good work

Thank you, Elfers, for the effort you put into your columns.

You got it wrong about Bernie

His supporters are not Democrats, and his fiscal policies are not irresponsible.

Confusing church and state is more baffling than ‘gay marriage’

If anything, the Supreme Court legalizing gay marriage expanded our country’s religious rights.

Thank you, Rotary, for giving big!

The local community group gave $5,000 to Plateau Outreach Ministries.