Driver pleads not guilty in fatal crash that killed two

Local Makyela Knaus, 13, was one of the victims.

The woman behind the wheel of a terrible car crash just outside Enumclaw, which took two lives and seriously hurt two others, is pleading not guilty to two counts of vehicular homicide and vehicular assault each.

Crystal Marie Mullin, 22, was driving west on state Route 164 on Dec. 4, 2018, with three passengers — Jacob Brown, 21, Charles Saylor, 18, and Makyela Knaus, 13 — when the car crossed over into the eastbound lane and collided with William Gatlin, 31.

None of the passengers in Mullin’s car were wearing seat belts. Brown and Knaus were killed when they were thrown from the car; Saylor suffered multiple fractured ribs and a leg, as well as internal injuries, and Mullin fractured her hip.

Gatlin, whose car rolled onto its passenger side and “slid into a power pole with such force the pole snapped in two and fell into the street,” court documents read, suffered deep lacerations to his hand and needed 20 stitches.

At the time, State Patrol troopers said they believed alcohol was a factor in the collision, as well as high speed and bad driving conditions.

According to the police report, Mullin’s tires were “obviously bald” and the car was going between 90 and 100 miles per hour when the collision occurred.

After the wreck, Mullin told police she had one beer before driving, but Saylor said they had been drinking hard alcohol. Blood alcohol tests appear to confirm she had a blood alcohol concentration of around 0.10 during the crash, which is above the legal limit.

At the time the crash was being reported, it was unclear why Knaus was in the car with Mullin. According to court documents, Mullin appears to have been living with Knaus’ father and step-mother.

Mullin was arrested June 10, and arraignment was June 13. Bail was set at $250,000. A trial date has not been set.




Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@courierherald.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.courierherald.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 500 words or less.

More in News

King County hosting virtual town hall Sept. 23

Check here for Zoom meeting information.

Enumclaw, Black Diamond police blotter | Sept. 1 – 10

Strange items around a dumpster, a suspicious Instacart driver, and a go-kart on the streets.

How Enumclaw families feel about sending kids back to school

Many, if not most, seem to feel comfortable sending students back into the classroom — with safety measures, of course.

Buckleyite finishes filming first movie on the Plateau

Ralph Smith’s movie, “Runaway”, is about a teenager who finds a mentor in a homeless veteran after she decides to take off on her own.

New CARES Act funds to be given directly to local businesses

If you have 60 or less employees and operate out of Enumclaw, then you’re eligible for up to $7,000.

Enumclaw food bank numbers dropping, despite pandemic

Food donations have increased, but clients just aren’t showing up.

In-paper debate, week 2: Leg. District 31 candidate rebuttals

This is part two of a debate between incumbent Drew Stokesbary and challenger Katie Young.

Enumclaw sees smattering of new COVID cases

Nearly two coronavirus-free weeks ended on Aug. 23.

Police chase ends with arrest of Tacoma man

Walter Dyches has a lengthy criminal history.

Most Read