Enumclaw's decision making tree

ESD students will not return until January

Many teachers and parents saw flaws in the plan for students to return to school after Thanksgiving, just to have them go on winter holiday a few weeks later.

Sending students back to school classrooms has proven to be a dicey proposal, as parents and educators continually weigh the benefits of in-class learning against COVID-related health risks.

It’s a conversation taking place across the nation as the pandemic rages and, with the holiday season in full swing, threatens to grow worse.

That is exactly the scenario that has been facing the Enumclaw School District, where youngsters in kindergarten through second grade were slated to return to their school buildings Nov. 30. Two weeks later, on Dec. 14, the district had planned for third- through fifth-graders to be in classrooms, as well.

Everything changed the morning of Nov. 20, however, when the district announced it was scrapping those plans.

The news was delivered by Superintendent Shaun Carey in a message sent to district families and shared with the greater community on the district’s website.

“Three weeks ago, we communicated our K-2 students would transition to the hybrid model on November 30th. Since that time, much of the landscape has changed….again,” Carey wrote. “We have faced significant challenges as we continue to experience COVID-19 cases in our staff and our students as a result of the heightened community transmission. Given these changes and what we expect to see as a result of the upcoming holiday season, we feel this transition is better timed to take place in January.”

The new schedule calls for K-2 students to return to schools on Jan. 11 and third- through fifth-graders to follow two weeks later on Jan. 25. The district’s secondary students, attending middle school or Enumclaw High, will head back on Feb. 1.

Students will be following a hybrid model in which they attend school two full days per week, with other days devoted to remote learning. Parents fearful of health risks will have the opportunity to keep their children in a fully-remote environment.

The district’s original plan had received plenty of comment the evening of Nov. 16, during a regularly-scheduled meeting of the Enumclaw School Board. The board’s agenda typically allows time for public comment and, on the 16th, the board heard plenty.

Comments came from those on both sides of the aisle – some in favor of getting kids back into schools and others who believe it remains a dangerous proposal. Offering input were both teachers and parents.

The district’s teachers were on record as opposing the original re-opening plan.

Among those addressing the school board on the 16th was Kathy Ross, a high school math teacher and president of the Enumclaw Education Association, which counts a current membership of more than 250 and represents classroom teachers and building specialists.

She reported that a survey of EEA members had generated “pretty overwhelming” opposition to the plan, stating that about 80 percent had disagreed with the district’s position. The primarily concern, Ross said, was timing: returning students to classrooms between the Thanksgiving and winter breaks, she said, “doesn’t make a lot of sense.”

Other district employees had asked for clarification regarding the health data used by the district, wondered about plans to cover for teachers who need to quarantine, and asked about mask-wearing enforcement.

Other district employees had supported the Nov. 30/Dec. 14 return-to-school plan. Comments included the willingness of the district to follow safety guidelines and the fact that some students are already on campus and have not contributed to increased infection rates.

Parents addressing the board were divided on the issue. Some told the school board that at-home students are at risk of falling behind, that the remote-learning model simply doesn’t work for everyone and not all parents are able to stay home with young children. Forcing students to stay at home, they said, ignores the social and emotional needs of young people.

Taking the opposite view were those opposed to the earlier re-opening plan. They spoke about the rising number of COVID cases throughout the county, the chance that younger students would not adequately follow safety protocols and the fact that the district has chosen to abandon the “Decision Tree” guidelines suggested by the state Department of Health.

When all had finished speaking, Board President Bryan Stanwood said the school board would be making a recommendation to district administrators. That process culminated in Friday morning’s announcement.

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@courierherald.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.courierherald.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 500 words or less.

More in News

West Point Treatment Plant in Seattle. Photo courtesy of King County
Power outages cause massive wastewater spill into Puget Sound, Lake Washington

King County estimates millions gallons of untreated wastewater overflowed into surrounding waters.

Democrats in the Washington State House are proposing to pay for transportation improvements partly by raising the gas tax by 18 cents. (Sound Publishing file photo)
House Democrats lay out massive $26B transportation package funded by gas tax hike

An 18-cent gas tax increase and a fee on carbon emissions would fund new roads and more.

File photo
Report: 70 percent of gun deaths in Washington are attributable to suicide

Research done at The Firearm Injury and Policy Research Program at Harborview… Continue reading

BECU scholarships open

High school seniors and college students can apply for a $2,500 scholarship.

June 2018 algae bloom. Photo courtesy of Department of Ecology
Human-caused ‘dead zones’ threaten health of Puget Sound

Wastewater treatment plants account for about 70% of the excess nutrients.

Robert Allen, 61, had never been homeless in his life before 2019, when he lost his housing. The chef has been trying to get back on his feet, and hopes to open a nonprofit and make hot sauce. File photo
King County implements 0.01% sales tax to raise money for housing the homeless

Officials plan to buy hotels, motels and nursing homes for conversion into permanent housing.

Former felons in Washington state can only get their voting rights back after serving time, parole, and probation. Image courtesy procon.org.
Bill promotes automatic right to vote for people released from prison

Currently, former felons in Washington can regain their right to vote after serving their sentence, parole, and probation.

City of Enumclaw council chambers
City looking for Arts Commission applicants

The Arts Commission meets at 4 p.m. on the first Wednesday of the month.

gavel and sounding block on desk
Alleged poisoner, molester trial date set

Allen W. Bittner is accused of poisoning his stepdaughter using home-made chloroform.

Most Read