City gives thumbs down to Nestlé

Ad-hoc committee follows suggestion of administration, says ‘no thanks'

  • Tuesday, December 9, 2008 2:27pm
  • News

Ad-hoc committee follows suggestion of administration, says ‘no thanks'

By Kevin Hanson – The Courier-Herald

Perhaps the shortest committee meeting in Enumclaw City Council history had a packed house cheering and clapping.

An ad hoc committee of the council had been appointed to study a proposal that would allow the giant Nestlé corporation to draw Enumclaw's natural spring water and build a bottling plant in the city.

After a quick review of the proposal during a Thursday committee meeting, Mark Bauer dropped a bombshell.

“We can find no support for the proposal in the community,” he said, so City Hall was recommending that the idea be dropped.

That's when the standing-room-only crowd burst into applause.

Councilman Kevin Mahelona concurred. “I don't think the council should spend time on it,” he said, when there appeared to be so little support from the public.

Councilman Jeff Beckwith's comments weren't received quite as well, but his hesitancy was lost in the crowd's excitement.

“I'm probably not going to get any applause,” he said, noting that he remained “50-50” on the proposal.

Beckwith said he had hoped the city would continue looking at the idea and gathering information. “Although I wish we were moving forward, I understand the reality,” he said, deferring to the suggestion from city administration.

With that, councilman and committee chairman Mike Ennis said the committee would recommend to the rest of the council that the Nestlé idea be scrapped and the ad hoc committee dissolved.

That action was expected to take place at Monday night's council meeting. The meeting came after press deadlines.

One person who wasn't cheering Thursday night was Dave Palais, Nestle´'s California-based natural resource manager.

Palais later noted his disappointment with the city's decision.

The brief, but emotionally-charged, relationship between Nestle and Enumclaw began last fall when the international corporation - which is responsible for product lines ranging from candy bars to pet food - approached the city, asking about the pristine water bubbling from Boise Spring.

For the city, Boise Spring is one source of water for the municipal supply.

Nestlé Waters North America is the No. 1 provider of bottled water in each of its identified markets. In this region, it bottles water under the Arrowhead label. And, while the company has facilities across North America, it has none in the Pacific Northwest.

Nestle floated a proposal in which the company would draw about 100 million gallons of water annually from Boise Spring and direct it to a bottling plant to be built in town. The plant, it was said, would be home to about 45 employees and operate 24 hours a day. Up to 120 trucks would pass through town daily to deliver the bottled water to market.

Bauer said city officials had talked with citizens face-to-face, on the phone and via e-mail and found support for the plan sorely lacking.

While disappointed that Enumclaw is no longer in the mix, Nestl isn’t´'t abandoning its plan for a Pacific Northwest facility, Palais said.

“We’re looking at a number of locations,” he said, noting that he'll soon be making a pitch before the Orting City Council.

Kevin Hanson can be reached at

More in News

The city of Maple Valley’s state Route 169 improvements will be made between Witte Road Southeast and Southeast 240th Street, the stretch of road just southeast of the city’s SR 18 interchange. Image courtesy of the city of Maple Valley
Improvements to SR 169 underway, may affect local commuters

If you drive north through Maple Valley, these road-widening projects will probably affect your arrival time.

Spiketon Bridge to get temporary repair

By next fall, a two-lane temporary bridge is expected to help ease Buckley traffic.

Dead passengers in fatal SR 164 crash identified

One of the passengers was a local middle schooler.

Following resignation, POM will again be searching for director

The board of directors met Dec. 12 to discuss the issue.

Flavored tobacco: a candy-coated addiction | Public Health Insider

Is it a candy? A juice box? Or liquid nicotine?

It was close, but Pierce library levy is approved

Only 951 more votes approved the levy than rejected it.

Mary Lynn Pannen, founder and CEO of Sound Options, has consulted thousands of Washington families on geriatric care for 30 years. Photo courtesy of Sound Options.
Elder abuse cases are on the rise in Washington

Local agencies and geriatric care managers aim to increase public awareness about the epidemic.

Chain-up or pay up on Snoqualmie | WSDOT

Not using chains or any other approved alternatives could net you a $500 ticket.

Bonney Lake man arrested in connection with drug ring

Charles Joslyn, 38, is being charged with helping smuggle and distribute heroin, crystal meth, and fentanyl-laced drugs in Washington.

Most Read