Kidnapper in Christopherson case pleads guilty to all charges

Maria Ann Counts was charged with the kidnapping and rape of Lily Chirstopherson of Bonney Lake last May.

Maria Ann Counts, who was arrested for the kidnapping, rape, and sexual exploitation of a Bonney Lake teenager, has pled guilty to all charges last week.

The dramatic saga began May 9, 2018, when Lily Christopherson disappeared from her home in the middle of the night.

This wasn’t the first time Christopherson, who was 15 at the time, had run away from home, but she always returned shortly afterward. However, it quickly became clear to her mother that something was terribly wrong — the passwords for email addresses Lily shared with her friends and Lily’s personal social media accounts had all been changed, and location information on her Facebook was erratic, “showing logins from Eastern Washington and random areas within minutes of each other,” court documents read.

By May 16, the Bonney Lake Police Department had started printing and distributing flyers asking for information about Lily and the last person she was believed to be with, Alex Thueringer.

Alex was picked up by police in Everett on May 20. He confirmed that they spent some time together on May 9, and said they had bused to Federal Way to meet up with who was eventually identified as Counts and her suspected accomplice, Christopher Fitzpatrick, 39.

Counts was arrested May 24 at a Motel 6 in Tumwater. However, neither Lily or Fitzpatrick were with her, and she told police she had left Fitzpatrick because he was more interested in Lily than her, court documents read.

Initially, she denied knowing Lily was underaged, but on several occasions said Lily was 17 years old. She eventually showed officers messages on her phone, which contained sexually explicit photos and appeared to show Counts and Fitzpatrick setting up “dates” for Lily and herself, documents read.

At first, Counts said none of the “dates” ever occurred, but then admitted later they had several together. She also told police Fitzpatrick had sexual contact with Lily several times, and he also provided Lily and Counts with drugs.

She further described Fitzpatrick as “a hacker” who routinely changed phones and the passwords of Counts’ various email and social media accounts.

Fitzpatrick was arrested in Lakewood on May 26, but he was not with Lily at the time.

Lily was spotted at a bus stop in Tacoma on June 3 by a passerby, and was reunited with her family.

Both Counts and Fitzpatrick were charged with first-degree kidnapping, promoting the commercial sexual abuse of a minor, two counts of third-degree rape, unlawful delivery of controlled substances to a minor, and second-degree possession of depictions of a minor engaged in sexually explicit conduct.

Just hours after his arraignment, Fitzpatrick tried and failed to hang himself in the Pierce County Jail.

Counts’ jury trial was due to begin Jan. 3, but the trial was moved up so Counts and Fitzpatrick would face the same jury as co-defenders on April 9, 2019.

She officially pled guilty to all charges Jan. 15, making her the third person in this case to plead guilty.

The other two were William Kent Pittman and Nicholas David Biancalana, who both pled guilty to third-degree rape of a child on Sept. 21, 2018.

CORRECTION: In the print version of this article, it was stated Counts and Fitzpatrick would a jury as co-defenders on April 9, 2018. The correct year is 2019.

More in News

Levy passage ensures Foothills Trail bridge connection

A new bridge could come as soon as 2021 or 2022.

From left to right: Plateau Outreach Ministries Director Elaine Olson, Outreach Case Manager for Veterans and Seniors Lisa Napolitano, and Director Elisha Smith-Marshall stand outside of their nonprofit’s office. The trio work together regularly to help lift up the vulnerable populations in Enumclaw, Black Diamond and Covington.
                                Photo by Danielle Chastaine
A mighty team of three help local vets and seniors

Plateau Outreach Ministries works with the county to repair vulnerable homes

Public invited to celebrate latest work on Enumclaw High campus

The ribbon cutting for the new music wing is Aug. 28 at 5 p.m., though the open house lasts until 8.

Changes to Black Diamond city code address attorney contracts

The city said it is clarifying the mayor has the power to hire and fire attorneys; some residents say this gives the mayor too much power.

Come meet Enumclaw’s first Miss Pro Rodeo at annual competition

Kristin Strudivan will be signing autographs before and after the rodeo, which is Aug. 22 - 24.

Trash talk: Enumclaw renews solid waste pact with King County

Additionally, the public comment period for the Cedar Hills Regional Landfill in Maple Valley is open through Aug. 26.

Taking a break from recording numbers, scientist Mauri Pelto balances on the walls of an ice chute to take footage of a water current on Columbia Glacier. (Zachariah Bryan / The Herald)
Chronicling the last years of a dying North Cascades glacier

For almost four decades, scientist Mauri Pelto has journeyed to measure the melting Columbia Glacier.

Fire Marshal releases firework incident numbers

More than 300 incidents were reported this year.

Local historical society celebrates Filipino heritage

The event is this weekend, Aug. 24, from 11 to 4 p.m.

Most Read