Wrongful death suit filed in Ellis family deaths

A wrongful death suit has been filed in the Pierce County Superior Court in the state Route 410 construction project in Bonney Lake that led to the deaths of Josh, Vanessa and Hudson Ellis.

The excavator at the job site on April 13 was not equipped with a “thumb”

A wrongful death suit has been filed in the Pierce County Superior Court in the state Route 410 construction project in Bonney Lake that led to the deaths of Josh, Vanessa and Hudson Ellis (click here for more information).

The wrongful death suit was filed on Aug. 27, four months after the family was killed by a falling concrete barrier on Angeline Road, and it brings to court all the parties involved in the project.

This includes construction companies WHH Nisqually Federal Services, Highmark Concrete Contractors, Staton Companies and Hamilton Construction/American Concrete Cutting, whose names have been at the forefront of several investigations since April.

McGee Engineering, a construction company that was not fined by Labor and Industries, and the city of Bonney Lake are also defendants in the wrongful death suit.

The plaintiffs in the suit are Zach Brown, the court appointed representative of the estates of the family and brother to Vanessa Ellis, and Diane Hess who is the mother of Vanessa. The plaintiffs are filing for damages against all parties involved in the construction project.

Highmark is the only company to answer the suit so far, which it did Sept. 22. In its answer, Highmark denied that each defendant involved in the SR 410 project is responsible for the death of the Ellis family, and specifically denies the company was negligent or that it caused injury.

Staton, Hamilton, WHH Nisqually, McGee and the city of Bonney Lake have declined to comment on the suit.

The Pierce County Prosecutor’s Office has not released a decision concerning any criminal prosecution in the case.

In October the state Department of Labor and Industries levied fines against four of the five construction companies involved in the project. (Click here for more information)

What is a wrongful death suit?

There are two kind of suits in cases like this, according to Kevin Sullivan, the attorney who represents the plaintiffs in this case.

The first type of claim is a wrongful death suit.

“That is for the losses suffered by the survivors of the decedent (dead person),” Sullivan said. “The entire immediate family was killed in the accident. In the statute, those would be what you would call ‘first tier beneficiaries.’ Next level beneficiaries are parents of the deceased.”

According to Sullivan, parents of adult decedents can only collect damages if they can prove to the court they were financially dependent on the deceased.

The only surviving family member that meets these requirements is Hess, who starting living with her daughter and Josh in 2013, rent-free.

Beginning in 2014, when the family bought a home in Bonney Lake, Hess started paying $500 in rent and the family paid all other house expenses, according to Hess’ declaration.

Currently, Hess is living with Brown and his wife, and wrote in her declaration that she still cannot financially support herself.

In addition to wrongful death suits, families of the deceased can also claim damages under the survival statute, no matter their financial status.

“Under the statutes, (this covers) the funeral expenses, their pre-death conscious pain and suffering, and the net-loss accumulations to their estate,” Sullivan said.

According to Sullivan, funeral expenses were minimal because they were picked up by the Ellis’ church, Eastpointe Foursquare Church.

Additionally, there are no pre-death conscious pain and suffering costs, because the Ellis family died instantly when the concrete barrier fell on top of their truck’s cab.

This only leaves the value of the Ellis’ estates in question. Josh, Vanessa and Hudson each have their own, but related, estate.

“What is the value of their estates? That’s a battle between different experts,” said Sullivan. “Work-life expectancy is one variable. The second is the discount rate that is applied to the income stream. The third is the personal accumulation rate of the individual decedent. All of those are in controversy, which they normally are.”

Sullivan declined discussing the specific monetary amounts the plaintiffs are looking for, but said, “The family trusts that the jury will do the right thing.”

The trial is currently set for Aug. 25, 2016 in the courtroom of Pierce County Judge Ronald Culpepper.


More in News

Former Plateau resident lands role with Marvel T.V. series

McKay Stewart, who spent much of his childhood in Enumclaw and Bonney Lake, will be joining the Marvel universe in a new episode of “Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.” airing Friday, Jan. 19.

Black Diamond hits the reset button

The new Black Diamond City Council wasted no time on settling in and testing the political waters. On their first meeting of the year, new Councilwomen Melissa Oglesbee and Erin Stout and returning Councilwomen Tamie Deady and Janie Edelman marched through a long list of agenda items, many of which reversed council policies and goals set over the last two years.

Citizen group urges council to start pool planning

With the Sumner High School pool closing at the end of the 2018-2019 swim season, residents are asking the City of Bonney Lake to build a city pool to house the Panther and Spartan swim teams. A presentation on why the council should start planning a pool as quickly as possible is being held Tuesday, Jan. 23.

Bonney Lake releases findings on water meter tests, ends internal audit

Dozens of residents complained to the council last October about what they called impossibly high water bills. After several months performing an internal audit of the water utility system, including testing 43 water meters from homes that received a high water bills, the city holds there is no bug in the system, and residents used the amount of water recorded on their bills. But some residents, and even councilmembers, remain unconvinced.

White River Valley Museum opens “Suffer for Beauty” exhibit

Corsets, bras, and bustles, oh my! The White River Valley Museum is hosting its new event, “Suffer for Beauty,” which is all about the changing ideals of female beauty through the ages. The exhibit runs through June 17.

Teacher, student reconnect at living center after 66 years

A person can change in 66 years. At the very least, they’re going to look pretty different. So when Robert Terrell, 96, and Margaret (Peggy) Burley, 75, ran into each other at Bonney Lake’s Cedar Ridge assisted living facility last August, neither of them realized they had met before — at an elementary school, where he was a fourth-grade teacher, and she was a part of his first ever class.

Library’s art and writing contest returns to Pierce County | Pierce County Library System

Pierce County teens are encouraged to express themselves through writing, painting, drawing and more for the annual Our Own Expressions competition, hosted by the Pierce County Library System.

Sumner School District seeks name ideas for new elementary school

Want to name your new local school? Just fill out a short form by Jan. 26

Judge reproaches Black Diamond mayor, former city council majority

In a summary judgement hearing, King County Superior Court Judge Janet Helson said she was troubled by both the actions of Black Diamond Mayor Carol Benson and former City Council majority Pat Pepper, Brian Weber, and Erika Morgan over the last two years concerning potential Open Public Meetings Act violations.

Most Read