"A man takes out a plastic bag from a pocket with a dose of cocaine or another concept of drugs." Photo courtesy Marco Verch, licensed under CC BY 2.0

"A man takes out a plastic bag from a pocket with a dose of cocaine or another concept of drugs." Photo courtesy Marco Verch, licensed under CC BY 2.0

State Supreme Court’s drug possession decision changes laws on the Plateau

Enumclaw is likely to adopt a new law decreasing the penalty of drug possession from a class C felony to a misdemeanor.

Drug possession laws will soon be changing on the Plateau, thanks to a recent Washington State Supreme Court decision.

For the month of April, the Enumclaw City Council has been preparing Ordinance No. 2707, which revises the city’s drug possession laws to reflect the Feb. 25 State v. Blake decision.

It’s unclear exactly what that means for Enumclaw at this moment.

“The effects of the Blake decision are unknown at this time,” said Enumclaw Police Department’s Commander Tim Floyd. “Only time will tell if this new case law and process for drug enforcement will actually be beneficial and helpful, or make the drug issues in all of our communities worse.”

If you’re not familiar with the Blake decision, here’s the gist.

In 2016, police in Spokane, WA, executed a search warrant looking for evidence of stolen cars, and arrested three people on the property, including defendant Shannon Blake. Once arrested, officers discovered a small bag of meth in the coin pocket of Blake’s jeans, and she was charged with possession.

However, Blake testified she had no idea there were drugs in that pocket, since a friend of hers bought the jeans secondhand and gave them to Blake just two days before the arrest.

The trial court found Blake guilty, and the appeals court held up those findings. But the state supreme court granted review and found that, in short, being charged with simply possessing drugs — knowingly or unknowingly — is unconstitutional, according to the Municipal Research and Services Center (MRSC).

“Washington’s strict liability drug possession statute… makes possession of a controlled substance a felony punishable by up to five years in prison, plus a hefty fine; leads to deprivation of numerous other rights and opportunities; and does all this without proof that the defendant even know they possessed the substance,” Judge J. Gordon McCloud wrote in his opinion. “Does this strict liability drug possession statute with these substantial penalties for such innocent, passive conduct exceed the legislature’s police power? The due process clauses of the state and federal constitutions, along with the controlling decisions of this court and the United States Supreme Court, compel us to conclude that answer is yes.”

This decision has repercussions statewide. According to the Department of Corrections, there are about 100 people in the state who are incarcerated only on a simple possession conviction, and about 7,000 who have been sentenced to community supervision on a simple possession conviction.

Additionally, the DOC has identified about 2,600 people currently incarcerated on a simple possession conviction and at least one other conviction, as well as another 3,900 people who are serving community supervision on a simple possession plus an additional conviction.


How the State v. Blake decision will impact Enumclaw, and the Plateau as a whole, is unclear, but adopting Ordinance No. 2707 is the first step.

The ordinance is fairly simple, as it models the state legislature’s Senate Bill 5476. As of April 28, the bill was on Gov. Jay Inslee’s desk awaiting his signature.

First, the ordinance will make it illegal to knowingly possess controlled substances unless it’s some sort of prescription or doctor’s order — “knowingly” being the new key word added to the books.

Second, the ordinance reduces the punishment for knowingly possessing controlled substances from a class C felony (up to five years in prison and/or a fine of $10,000) to a misdemeanor (a jail sentence of 90 days and/or a $1,000 fine).

(A previous version of the ordinance stipulated knowingly possessing controlled substances would be considered a gross misdemeanor).

Floyd indicated that the ordinance won’t much change how the EPD goes about its business.

“In my 23 years of law enforcement, the industry has faced many changes and challenges stemming from case law decisions,” Floyd wrote in an email interview. “The Blake decision will be no different, we will adapt to the changes and continue to provide the highest level of customer service and safety for community that we can within the rules and regulations that are set forth for us.”

However, Floyd added that “it’s difficult to say” right now whether or not the EPD will continue enforcing drug possession laws. Other police departments, like in Seattle, have decided to stop confiscating, arresting, or detaining people solely for simple drug possession, the Seattle Times reported.

“Generally speaking, when we encounter criminal drug possession, the drug possession itself is an inevitable discovery related to a separate crime which we will enforce,” Floyd continued.

Ordinance No. 2707 is expected to make an appearance during the Enumclaw City Council’s May 11 meeting, when it will likely be adopted.

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@courierherald.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.courierherald.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 500 words or less.

More in News

The Blues Brothers was one of the acts to grace the Buckley Concert Series in 2019. The 2020 concert series was canceled due to the pandemic. This year, the Blues Brothers will not be making an appearance during the series. Photo by Kevin Hanson
Free and outdoors, summer concerts set for Enumclaw, Buckley

Rock n’ roll, blues, jazz and more coming July, August

King County logo
Auditors find racial disparities in King County contracts

BIPOC-owned businesses earn contract bids at a much lower rate than white-owned businesses.

Blotter bug
Black Diamond police blotter | May 24 – 30

Vehicle prowls, a civil standby and burglary

Enumclaw High senior Meredth Petellin with her award-winning piece of art, "Liberty and Justice." Photo by Ray Miller-Still
EHS artist named winner of annual OSPI art contest

Senior Meredith Petellin made her piece, “Liberty and Justice” as a way to wrap her mind about police brutality and the BLM movement.

Colette Sweers, left, and her boyfriend Trevor Curley spent part of their day in Enumclaw June 2 shopping at The Sequel Books.
The business of reopening on the Plateau

How local shops and customers are navigating health, privacy and business

Construction expert Will Martin taking some measurement of the siding of a house in Enumclaw’s Suntop Farms. Photo by Ray Miller-Still
Class action lawsuit filed against LGI Homes in Enumclaw

Plaintiffs allege developer is responsible for “defective construction”

This scooter, along with other prizes, could be yours if you donate to Bloodworks Northwest this summer.
Donate blood, win an electric scooter, sports memorabilia

Regional non-profit Bloodworks Northwest faces a shortage of blood donations

Alyxandra Bozeman, a senior at White River High, will serve as state FFA president for the next year. Photo by Kevin Hanson
White River’s Bozeman chosen to lead state FFA for the next year

Alyxandra Bozeman officially took on her new duties last month.

Blotter bug
Black Diamond police blotter | May 16 – 23

Cat scratches on a car, stolen appliances, and several DUIs.

Most Read