These are the proposed impact fees the four school districts in Black Diamond would like to see implemented, although it’s up to the Black Diamond City Council to decide how much the fee will actually be. Screenshot

These are the proposed impact fees the four school districts in Black Diamond would like to see implemented, although it’s up to the Black Diamond City Council to decide how much the fee will actually be. Screenshot

Black Diamond talks school impact fees

If passed by the council, these impact fees would require housing developers to pay thousands to local school districts for every single- and multi-family home.

The Black Diamond City Council discussed a number of exciting topics during their last meeting, including setting up a school impact fee ordinance.

However, before work began on the Aug. 6 meeting, Councilman Patrick Nelson made a surprise announcement.

“This is hard. I’m officially stepping down as a council member,” he said, adding that he’s had to move out of the city to help family. “I’m not going away, I’m just not living there… you’ll still see me around.”

Of course, this means Nelson’s seat — which he himself was appointed to on Sept. 19, 2019 — will be open once again, and the city will soon start accepting applications to name a new appointee.

After Nelson recused himself of any further votes, the council began talking about implementing school impact fees.

For those not in the know, impact fees of any kind are a one-time charge on new housing developments that can go toward various amenities that would be put under more strain because of those additional housing units. This idea falls under the colloquial “growth paying for growth” umbrella.

Impact fees can collect money for anything from transportation and traffic, parks, fire protection, or, in this case, schools.

However, impact fees are not a silver bullet when it comes to population growth helping mitigate school costs, and there are strict rules.

For example, while school districts are often relied upon to calculate how much revenue they’d need to see to keep up with the population growth of their area, local cities decide exactly how much the impact fee will actually be, and according to the Washington-based Municipal Research and Services Center, it’s very common for cities (or school districts) to automatically cut the impact fee in half.

While school impact fees can pay for any sort of system improvements, the revenue cannot be spent on improvements that were already needed when the school impact fees are adopted.

“If there’s a lack of space already existing or other facilities that needed to be built anyway, regardless of growth, the impact fees are not appropriate for those purposes,” said city attorney David Linehan.

Additionally, school impact fees cannot be the sole source of revenue for a school project or improvement.

“There must be some general revenue that is used,” Linehan added.

Finally, commercial developments are not affected by impact fees, and exceptions or waivers can be made for certain kinds of housing developments, like low-income housing or auxiliary dwelling units (ADUs), to encourage developers to build more of certain kinds of housing.

There are two reasons why Black Diamond is seriously looking at ways to increase support for their area schools.

First is that the Ten Trails and Lawson Hills housing developments, which fall under a Master Plan Development by developer Oakpoine, are expected to increase the city’s population from around 4,200 to more than 19,000. This would put a strain on any school district, even though that population increase is expected to occur at a steady pace over a couple of decades.

Second, Black Diamond doesn’t reside in one school district, but four — Enumclaw, Tahoma, Kent, and Auburn.

“Adopting the impact fee ordinance would ensure that all the [housing] development in the city is providing mitigation for schools,” said Linehan. “Right now, outside of the Ten Trails development, there are no residential developments that have to pay school mitigation. By adopting this ordinance, all the resident development in the city will be covered.”

While Black Diamond doesn’t currently have school impact fees established in city code, the city, Oakpointe, and the Enumclaw School Districted signed in 2011 a Comprehensive School Mitigation Agreement (CSMA) which acts very similar to school impact fees; for every single-family housing unit built in Ten Trails or Lawson Hills, the Enumclaw School District gets $7,783, and for every multi-family housing unit, $2,502.

Based on Enumclaw’s calculations on how Black Diamond growth will impact the school district, the district would actually like to receive $8,972 and $6,282 for single- and multi-family housing developments respectively.

However, based on the CSMA, the district will actually be limited to a maximum impact fee of $4,003 for multi-family housing.

The Kent School District is requesting impact fees of $5,692 for single-family home development and $2,403.63 for multi-family developments; the Tahoma District $5,748 for single-family and $4,366 for multi-family; and Auburn wants $6,456.31 for single-family (the city of Auburn has a sliding scale for multi-family developments ranging from $6,325 for studio apartments to $16,325 for four-bedroom townhouses or larger).

During the public hearing, many Black Diamond residents and advocates voiced concern about the 50 percent discount normally imposed on impact fees, saying they’d like Oakpointe (and other developers) to more in school impact fees.

Additional discussion about the impact fees, and a vote of the council whether or not to implement them, are expected during the Aug. 20 meeting.

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 500 words or less.

More in News

In addition to traveling through Enumclaw and Buckley, Santa will also be at the Enumclaw Expo Center's Hometown Holiday Parade Dec. 4 - 6, in place of being a part of the normal Enumclaw holiday parade. File photo
Santa to visit Buckley, Enumclaw neighborhoods

Make sure you know when Old Saint Nick is traveling through your area Dec. 7 - 12.

Feel free to use this image, just link to www.SeniorLiving.Org
Buckley budget includes money for streets, recreation projects

Residents can look forward to work being done on River Avenue and a new athletic court.

Enumclaw's decision making tree
ESD students will not return until January

Many teachers and parents saw flaws in the plan for students to return to school after Thanksgiving, just to have them go on winter holiday a few weeks later.

Sage Viniconis is a career performing artist in King County who’s been out of work and seeking creative outlets during the COVID-19 pandemic. Courtesy photo/Sage Viniconis
Puget Sound artists adapt creativity, and business sense, to pandemic

Artists Sunday is an online directory that connects artists across the county, state and nation.

The Courier-Herald is moving to a paid-subscription model. Photo by Ray Miller-Still
Dec. 2 is the last free edition of the Courier-Herald

When you subscribe to a newspaper, you’re not just receiving a product, but investing in an idea.

One of the highlights of Holiday Fantasy has been outright donations to a worthy cause. Here, attendees show their support during the 2018 event. This year, the event will be holding a virtual auction over four days. Photo by Kevin Hanson
Holiday Fantasy goes virtual, offers four days of silent auction

The annual Rainier Foothills Wellness Foundation fundraiser helps fund nearly a third of the non-profits various programs, from feeding seniors to arranging transport to medical appointments.

File photo
Snow Lake, located near Snoqualmie Pass in Mt. Baker-Snoqualmie National Forest.
Washington releases new forest plan

It outlines ways the state will protect and maintain forest health.

Still from the movie
New horror movie filmed in Enumclaw

“They Reach” was written and directed by a former local, who wanted to show off Enumclaw in his first-ever feature-length film.

City of Buckley's Merry and Bright competition
Buckley hosts first-ever holiday decoration competition

The deadline to register your home is Dec. 4.

Most Read