Doing business, a decade goes fast for Babbitt Insurance

The 10 years since David Babbitt purchased one of Enumclaw’s older insurance companies have flown.

The 10 years since David Babbitt purchased one of Enumclaw’s older insurance companies have flown.

The Babbitt Insurance Group, which celebrated its 10-year anniversary June 1, came together when Babbitt, an Enumclaw High School graduate, left one of the largest insurance agencies in the world, Arthur J. Gallagher of Tacoma. He hired his father, the late Leroy Babbitt, a longtime EHS coach and teacher, and Doug Wagner, also an EHS graduate, and purchased the McCauley Insurance Agency from Dale and Alice McCauley. Both Wagner and the elder Babbitt also were working for a large agency in Tacoma at the time.

Alice McCauley had worked for the original agency owner, James Puttman, who started the agency around 1958, combining now for more than 50 years on the Plateau.

“It is fun to think back 10 years,” Babbitt said. “Ten very quick years at that – to what was started then and to look at the pictures from when we first walked through the agency doors.

“Ten years, wow, it goes by fast. My daughter was 6 and my son 7 months old. Now I can’t beat either one of them on the golf course. Time flies when having fun and helping others.”

Babbitt said the agency takes a counselor approach to insurance.

“We are not salespeople looking to make a sale,” he said. “We are counselors looking to talk to our clients, to decipher what their particular needs are, then put together a program from one of our preferred or specialty companies to fit their specific concerns.

“We are a local business helping local families and actively participating in the local communities.”

The office is filled with familiar faces, like Wagner, who this year was made a junior partner at the agency.

In the personal lines department, customers will find EHS graduates Cindy Streuli, Lynn Pratt, Mallorie Lawson and Sumner High graduate Gertie Huff. On the commercial side are EHS graduate Lee Campbell and Kent-Meridian graduate Janet Gunter.

Bob Jacobowitz is the agency’s full-time firefighter/part-time insurance agent working out of the Seattle waterfront fire station. He brings 20 years of insurance experience wit him.

EHS graduate Connie Johnson handles the agency’s accounting and financial aspects.

The agency has represented Mutual of Enumclaw since 1958 and, Babbitt noted, it has been recognized as one of the top five companies in the nation for  outstanding claims service.

“That is very impressive for a regional carrier and fun that they are based here in our home town,” he said.

“If we could, we would thank all of our clients individually, those that are with us now, and those that we have had the pleasure of working with in the past,” Babbitt said. “In 10 years it is easy to remember family’s having to struggle through major losses and we take pride in having helped them to put their lives back together.”


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 500 words or less.

More in Business

Health Bar owner Heidi Hawkinson preparing a mango smoothie. Photo by Ray Miller-Still
The Health Bar opens on Enumclaw’s Blake Street

The new “fast food” joint serves smoothies and salads for health-conscious eaters.

Don Brunell
‘Work from home’ is here to stay | Brunell

Working from home jumped 12,000 percent last year, and 42 percent of the labor force is working from home full time.

2021 Ford F-150 Platinum. Courtesy photo
Car review: 2021 Ford F-150 Platinum

By Larry Lark, contributor It’s always a call to action when a… Continue reading

The Cadillac CT4 is designed to appeal to a new generation of Cadillac buyers with its athletic design and astute driving dynamics. Courtesy photo
Car review: 2020 Cadillac CT4 Premium Luxury

By Larry Lark, contributor With apologies to Oldsmobile, “the 2020 CT4 Premium… Continue reading

2021 Mercedes E-350 luxury sedan. Courtesy photo
Car review: 2021 Mercedes E-350 luxury sedan

By Larry Lark, contributor Mercedes-Benz occupies rarified air in the automobile pantheon.… Continue reading

737 MAX 7 Reveal - February 5, 2018. File photo
Boeing fined $2.5 billion for deceiving aircraft safety regulators

The Boeing Company has agreed to pay the Department of Justice over… Continue reading

Photo courtesy of Fisher Scones
Fisher Scones parent company fined for overworking teenage employees

Washington State Department of Labor and Industries found more than 1,500 instances of violations including missing meal breaks, working during school hours and more.

Don Brunell
Introducing wind blade cement | Brunell

Using old wind turbine blades in concrete reduces CO2 emissions by 27 percent.

Don Brunell
E-waste reduction requires innovative approaches | Brunell

Less than 13 percent of electronics are recycled — the rest is dumped.

Enumclaw Mayor Jan Molinaro
Shop Enumclaw first

A message from Enumclaw Mayor Jan Molinaro.

Don Brunell
Boeing’s good news | Brunell

Boeing’s revamped 737MAX to ready to return to service.